updated 08/08/2014 AT 10:00 AM ET
•originally published 08/08/2014 AT 11:55 AM ET
So this is what things really look like after the final rose.
In honor of Throwback Thursday, former Bachelorette Andi Dorfman shared a snapshot of her cuddling with fiancé Josh Murray the day after the two were engaged on the show’s finale.
“#tbt Day after we got engaged @joshmurray!!” Dorfman, 27, captioned the cute photo on Instagram.
Murray, a former baseball player, proposed to the former assistant district attorney in the Dominican Republic with a stunning Neil Lane sparkler.
Although the couple look completely relaxed in the picture, Dorfman made Murray, 29, sweat before finally revealing her feelings for the season frontrunner.
“In the middle of my proposal, I stopped to allow her to gather her words. I assumed she was finally going to tell me she loved me, but it didn’t start out like that!” Murray joked to PEOPLE.