07/24/2014 AT 11:35 AM ET
In an exclusive sneak peek at the episode airing Monday, Dorfman, 27, tells her dad, Hy, and mom, Patti, that “it’ll be interesting to see what you guys think” about her final two: Josh Murray and Nick Viall.
Hy, who put ex-soccer pro Juan Pablo Galavis through the wringer on the last season of The Bachelor, isn’t impressed when his daughter tells him that Murray is a former professional baseball player. “As far as Josh being an athlete, she says it’s different,” Hy says.
Murray, 29, admits he’s “very nervous” about coming face-to-face with Andi’s family. “Today is a very big day,” he says. “It’s a big deal to get their approval and just get to show them who I am and how much I care for her.”
He plans to ask her father for Andi’s hand in marriage and says, “You only get one chance to make one first impression and this is it.”