updated 05/21/2014 AT 11:30 AM ET
•originally published 05/20/2014 AT 11:05 PM ET
Up for the mirror ball trophy were season frontrunners Meryl Davis and Maksim Chmerkovskiy, along with Amy Purdy and Derek Hough and Candace Cameron Bure and Mark Ballas.
After the three couples danced their fusion routines that combined two different ballroom styles, Bure was eliminated first, followed by Purdy.
That meant Winter Olympic gold medal ice dancer Davis took the Dancing crown – and made Chmerkovskiy a first-time pro champ.
“It means so much,” Chmerkovskiy said after the big announcement. “If you do it with Meryl, it’s a dream come true. There’s a reason it didn’t happen before. It was meant to happen with this one.”
During the night’s final dances, Davis and Chmerkovskiy got the most praise from the judges.
“The best part of the season for me was you two,” Carrie Ann Inaba told the pair. The other judges agreed and gave them a perfect 30 out of 30.
Purdy and Hough also received a flawless score, with judge Bruno Tonioli telling the Paralympian, “Your dancing is right up there with the best.”
Bure and Ballas’s routine got a 27, but Tonioli raved about the actress, saying, “You’ve always been adorable, charming, genuine.”