updated 07/07/2014 AT 1:00 PM ET
•originally published 07/07/2014 AT 1:45 PM ET
The new video, released Monday morning, shows similar scenes to the film’s first look as Nick (Ben Affleck) joins the national search for his wife – now interposed with eerie voiceovers from Amy’s infamous diary.
“I will practice believing my husband loves me,” she whispers. “But I could be wrong.”
The trailer also gives a glimpse of the supporting stars Neil Patrick Harris and Tyler Perry.
The four posters, published Sunday by Entertainment Weekly, display evidence bags filled with objects linked to Amy’s disappearance: a photo, scalpel, red thong and threatening note torn from her diary.
They sure looks suspicious, but as lovers of the book know, not everything is as it seems during the spellbinding investigation.