03/07/2009 AT 4:10 PM ET
A second chance at love didn’t work.
Despite a reconciliation that gave them both cause for laughs, late-night talk-show host Jimmy Kimmel, 41, and comedian Sarah Silverman, 38, have split, a source confirms to PEOPLE.
No reason was revealed for their second breakup. The funny duo dated for five years before they called it quits last July. But they rekindled their relationship just a few months later. “They’re taking it slow,” a source told PEOPLE last fall. “They’re on the road back to being together.”
The pair even managed to poke fun of their first split on Jimmy Kimmel Live! last October when she was a guest and they exchanged awkward silences and quips like, “Did you make sweet love to anyone while we were apart?”
Comedic duo Sarah & Jimmy named Funniest Couple Alive!
Read about more celeb breakups on the covers of PEOPLE
From Sarah to Tina, match funny ladies in Celeb Concentration!