updated 07/30/2009 AT 9:00 AM ET
•originally published 07/30/2009 AT 9:30 AM ET
One is the daughter of Hollywood royalty, and won a Golden Globe nomination for a 2006 performance in a Shakespeare adaptation. The other is a bilingual Canuck who likes an active role – and loves vampire books. But only one of the two – Bryce Dallas Howard, or the woman she’s replacing in the Twilight series’ Eclipse, Rachelle Lefevre – can play evil bloodsucker Victoria. Who do you think it should be?