updated 10/22/2009 AT 11:00 AM ET
•originally published 10/22/2009 AT 12:30 PM ET
The pair were spotted having dinner and acting flirtatious Tuesday night at Soho House in New York City Tuesday, where they sat with friends who included Simpson pal, the hairstylist Ken Paves, according to the New York Post’s Page Six.
But sources say the hullabaloo is probably over nothing.
A source tells PEOPLE: “They have a mutual friend in common, and they all went out to dinner together.”