01/04/2011 AT 8:15 PM ET
Ask Cee Lo what he thought of Gwyneth Paltrow’s version of his hit song on Glee, and he responds with an F-word.
“She sings like a natural,” says Cee Lo, who was so impressed that he and Paltrow have recorded a new version of “F—- You.”
They were at work at studio MSR in New York over the weekend and again on Monday afternoon, he tells PEOPLE exclusively.
And that’s not the end of it. They’ll meet again when Paltrow hosts Saturday Night Live on Jan. 15 when Cee Lo performs.