updated 03/15/2011 AT 8:00 AM ET
•originally published 03/14/2011 AT 10:05 PM ET
Brad Womack’s first stint on The Bachelor in 2007 didn’t end so well. The Texas bar owner famously walked away from his final two women, leaving both in tears and earning him a reputation as someone with a phobia of commitment.
But is it 28-year-old Seattle executive assistant Chantal O’Brien, who made a lasting first impression on Womack when she declared, “This is for all the women in America,” and slapped him across the face? Or did demure Charlotte, N.C., single mom Emily Maynard, 25, win his heart?
Keep reading to find out …