updated 05/26/2011 AT 1:00 PM ET
•originally published 05/26/2011 AT 4:45 PM ET
They say a kiss is just a kiss but was it romantic, friendly or just congratulatory?
Are they an item? “Oh no,” McCreery, 17, said during a conference call on Thursday. “We’ve been getting that question all morning. Me and her – it’s a brother-and-sister relationship.”
As for the kiss, McCreery knew Alaina, 16, was going to do it if he won.
“She told me before the show she was going to [kiss me],” he said. “It was kind of like a joke. She’s a character.”
The finalists – the youngest pair to compete in an Idol finale – have a lot more in common than both being country singers on the rise.