updated 01/17/2012 AT 6:45 AM ET
•originally published 01/16/2012 AT 6:45 PM ET
What started as innocent fun with friends turned into an arrest for reality star Kasey Kahl – and one heck of a mug shot.
The former Bachelor Pad and Bachelorette star, 27 – who is also the ex-boyfriend of Vienna Girardi – was taken into custody at 2:47 a.m. Sunday at Club Habanos in Fresno, Calif., authorities tell E! Online.
Kahl was booked on a drunk-and-disorderly-conduct charge, and released around 8:30 a.m.
His rep Richard Harlow tells PEOPLE Kahl is “shaken by the circumstances,” but also “a bit confused as to what happened.”