updated 04/06/2012 AT 4:05 PM ET
•originally published 04/06/2012 AT 6:30 PM ET
Their Manhattan romp continued Thursday night when Kardashian, stunning in sky-high black heels and a creme-colored blouse, dined with the rapper and three friends, including makeup artist Joyce Bonelli, at Cafeteria. Looking happy together at the trendy Chelsea eatery, they shared a plate of fried chicken, waffles and macaroni and cheese.
“They entered through a secret door and dined in Cafeteria’s brand new [private dining room] to have some privacy,” a source tells PEOPLE. “Kim and Kanye sat together, and she kept taking pictures of him on her cell phone. It was cute.”
The source adds: “They had fun, but were very low-key.”
Prior to their dinner out, the new couple enjoyed a movie date on Wednesday, in which they reportedly saw The Hunger Games. They were also spotted hitting up FAO Schwarz and lunching at Serafina, Kardashian’s favorite N.Y.C. eatery, on Thursday.
“Kanye and I have been friends for years,” Kardashian said on Friday’s Today show of their relationship (West and Kardashian are longtime pals, and the rapper has even made appearances on the star’s E! show). “You never know what the future holds.”