updated 05/09/2012 AT 3:00 PM ET
•originally published 05/09/2012 AT 4:20 PM ET
On May 7, the couple was spotted taking a ferry to the Vancouver Island city of Nanaimo. A few hours later, they were seen dining at the Blue Ginger Restaurant downtown along with Reynolds’s brother and his wife.
“The couple came in and had a very enjoyable evening,” a source tells PEOPLE. “They were both casually dressed and sat with their backs to the rest of the room. They stayed for a couple of hours and enjoyed several Asian dishes off the menu.”
On Tuesday afternoon, Reynolds and Lively were spotted at the Duke Point Ferry Terminal, where they picked up drinks and sandwiches before boarding the boat for the approximately two-hour ferry ride back to the mainland.
– Christine Kilpatrick