updated 05/22/2012 AT 9:00 PM ET
•originally published 05/22/2012 AT 9:30 PM ET
In one corner, you have Jessica Sanchez, whom host Ryan Seacrest called a “16-year-old powerhouse.” In the other, you have Phillip Phillips, a crooning pawnshop worker from Leesburg, Ga. Both faced off Tuesday by performing three songs each: show creator Simon Fuller chose round one, Phillips and Sanchez selected their favorite song from the season for round two, and in the final round, both picked the song that will become the winning single as the next American Idol.
How’d they do? Here’s a round-by-round recap: