updated 10/08/2012 AT 9:20 AM ET
•originally published 10/08/2012 AT 4:50 PM ET
Kym Johnson is a two-time Dancing with the Stars champion, taking the coveted mirror ball trophy in season 9 with Donny Osmond and in season 12 with Hines Ward. The Australia native blogged for PEOPLE.com about competing with Joey Fatone in the all-star season. The pair was unfortunately sent home during the second week of competition. Johnson is sharing her final elimination post below.
I was surprised we were sent home.
We didn’t have terrible scores. We were kind of in the middle of the pack. We just had so much more we wanted to do. I was so excited about Monday’s dance, so I’m more upset that I didn’t get to do that.
I’m disappointed. We were having a lot of fun. I knew it was going to be tough every week, but I wasn’t expecting to be gone so soon.
I know the judges have to critique and that’s their job, but I was a little bit upset Len said that Joey can’t dance and can only entertain. I think it came out worse than what he wanted it to be, but I felt like the judges were pretty hard on us. But then again, we got good scores.