updated 10/10/2012 AT 11:00 AM ET
•originally published 10/10/2012 AT 12:35 PM ET
Tuesday’s second night of the Battle Rounds on The Voice made for some intense duos between contestants and brought out the passion from the coaches.
Team Adam’s Caitlin Michele and Melanie Martinez surprised the coaches by packing two very different, yet powerful, punches. Christina Aguilera praised both for their sweet, haunting take on Ellie Goulding’s “Lights.”
Every coach had difficulty choosing between the distinctive songstresses, but Adam Levine stuck with Martinez and her breathy, soft vocals. Cee Lo Green and Blake Shelton fought it out for the honor of bringing Michele and her bold, clear tone to their teams, with Green coming out the winner.
This was the second time Michele passed on Team Blake, much to Shelton’s dismay.