updated 10/22/2012 AT 10:15 AM ET
•originally published 10/22/2012 AT 8:00 AM ET
“It was magical,” Timberlake, 31, tells PEOPLE exclusively. “It was an unforgettable evening.”
Surrounded by close friends and family, the pair became husband and wife after days of pre-wedding celebrations leading up to the event.
“It was a fantasy,” Biel, 30, tells PEOPLE of the nuptials, which will be featured exclusively in this week’s PEOPLE magazine, debuting online Wednesday.