Bachelor Poll: Vote for Your Favorite Guy from 17 Seasons

Clockwise from top left: Lorenzo Borghese, Andrew Baldwin, Brad Womack, Matt Grant, Jason Mesnick, Jake Pavelka, Ben Flajnik and Sean Lowe

ABC (8)

updated 04/04/2013 AT 11:00 AM ET

originally published 04/05/2013 AT 9:00 AM ET

They were always there “for all the right reasons.” And even now, after 25 combined seasons of The Bachelor and The Bachelorette, fans still haven’t gotten tired of the drama, cat fights, and hot tub hijinks that make for an amazing season.

Who should win as the best Bachelor of all: Jake Pavelka, who chose bad-girl Vienna only to break up with her in a vicious televised special? Sean Lowe, who vowed to hold off on sex with his pick, Catherine Giudici, until their summer 2013 wedding night? Or Jason Mesnick, who popped the question to Melissa Rycroft, then pulled a switcheroo at the reunion? (He just had a baby with his final choice, Molly Malaney.) And remember Season 2 star Aaron Buerge? He ranks as the highest rated Bachelor of all time, with 26 millions viewers tuning in as he popped the question to Helene Eksterowicz in 2002.

After 16 sexy men (Brad Womack tried twice!) and only one marriage resulting from a match made on the show, vote for who you think was best.


From Our Partners