updated 04/11/2013 AT 1:15 PM ET
•originally published 04/11/2013 AT 1:40 PM ET
Well, this is an interesting Bachelor twist!
Emily Maynard’s ex-fiancé, 40, was pictured in an Instagram photo this week, hugging Frazier, 32. Accompanying the cutesy shot was a revealing caption from Frazier, herself, who made it known she and Womack are an item.
“Game day,” the smiling reality star wrote. “Who’s the real winner here? #Astros #twoTexaskids #wgt.”
Maynard announced her split from Womack to PEOPLE in June 2011. Frazier was among the three remaining finalists during her season with Lowe, who eventually gave his final rose to current fiancée, Catherine Giudici.
Calls to Womack and a Bachelor rep were not immediately returned.