updated 04/23/2013 AT 6:30 PM ET
•originally published 04/23/2013 AT 1:45 PM ET
Hold on to your buggy, the stars of Breaking Amish are back.
Abe, Rebecca, Kate, Sabrina and Jeremiah will reunite with hopes of starting fresh. But whether it’s culture shock, family members from home, love triangles, partying or religious differences, the show’s stars, who are now leading “English” lives, seem to find more trouble than sunshine in Sarasota, where they’re living in the thriving Amish community of Pinecraft, Fla.
“It’s an old Amish saying that you don’t need to call the devil. The devil will come without you calling it,” Kate says in a trailer for the show (above).
Breaking Amish: Brave New World premieres May 12 (10 p.m. ET) on TLC.