updated 09/12/2013 AT 8:00 AM ET
•originally published 09/12/2013 AT 8:15 AM ET
Lillie McCloud, a 54-year-old Florida mother of three and grandmother of seven, took the stage in a leather bodysuit, looking half her age and a little like Halle Berry in Catwoman. She belted out “Alabaster Box” by CeCe Winans, bringing Rowland to tears and prompting Lovato to say, “I feel like I’m listening to Whitney!”
Then, 13-year-old Rion Paige, who was born with a birth defect of her hands, wowed the judges with a version of “Blown Away” by Carrie Underwood.
“I’m going to remember this audition for a long time,” Simon said, adding that Rion reminded him of the fourth American Idol winner.
Spears even made a cameo – sort of. The boyfriend-girlfriend duo of Alex & Sierra performed a stripped-down, folksy version of her song “Toxic” that earned them a unanimous pass to the next round. Their version gave Demi chills. (Check them out below.)