updated 09/22/2013 AT 9:00 AM ET
•originally published 09/22/2013 AT 9:35 AM ET
Brooklyn Nine-Nine star Andy Samberg married singer-songwriter Joanna Newsom Saturday, his rep confirms to PEOPLE.
The Saturday Night Live alum, 35, and his girlfriend of five years tied the knot in Big Sur at the Post Ranch Inn.
The bride wore a custom Zac Posen gown and a one-of-a-kind tiara and custom earrings by Irene Neuwirth. The groom wore a custom David Hart suit.
Samberg and Newsom, 31, have been engaged since February.
But on the thought of collaborating professionally, the comedian told Glamour magazine, “We’ve talked about it. But we’ve decided ultimately that her fans would probably murder me in my sleep. What she does is so, like, actually beautiful and important.”