updated 02/20/2014 AT 2:00 AM ET
•originally published 02/20/2014 AT 6:30 AM ET
It may have been ladies night Tuesday on American Idol, but the boys stole the spotlight Wednesday.
Once again, the judges only called to the stage the 10 singers who impressed them most, eliminating the remaining five.
Rocker Caleb Johnson, 22, kicked things off and stayed true to form with “Stay With Me,” a “real rock star” performance according to Jennifer Lopez, who added, “It’s your time.”
Guitar teacher C.J. Harris, 23, brought some country soul and a big smile, despite undergoing a root canal Tuesday, to his performance of “Shelter.”