updated 03/31/2014 AT 7:00 PM ET
•originally published 03/31/2014 AT 9:10 PM ET
In a world where cutting to black (The Sopranos) or sending your characters to prison (Seinfeld) passes for a series finale, How I Met Your Mother’s ender was decidedly sweet and complete.
While some critics have harshed on this season, the CBS sitcom did a terrific job of tying up all sorts of loose ends (The Mother has a name! The Cockamouse lives!) Except one, that is.
“I know a nagging question from the show might be released as a DVD extra and I did shoot it,” says Josh Radnor who plays Ted. (Filming of the series wrapped in early March.) “But I feel I might not have approval to say what it is, so I’m just going to plead the Fifth.”
As Barney would say, “Please!” No? Okay, we’ll fill in the loose ends. EW has learned the scene Radnor referenced will be included on HIMYM’s season 9 DVD.