updated 04/02/2014 AT 7:00 AM ET
•originally published 04/02/2014 AT 8:05 AM ET
She might be from another galaxy, but Team Blake’s Sisaundra Lewis proved she’s got the “sick, sick, sick” talent to earn her an extended stay.
The Voice’s second round of battles continued Tuesday with a masterful performance by Lewis, a former vocal director for Céline Dion (yes, really), and Biff Gore, a father of six coach Blake Shelton stole from Team Usher.
The duo’s showstopping rendition of James Brown’s “It’s a Man’s, Man’s, Man’s World” brought all four coaches to their feet – and they became effusive with their praise.
“The commitment Sisaundra has, you can tell every ounce of it is real,” Levine also said. “Biff, you have the same thing Sisaundra has, the ability to go out and say, ‘I’m going to feel this.’ All we ever try to teach anybody on this show is what you guys did.”
Chris Martin a Guest Mentor
Shelton echoed the praise his fellow coaches showered on both his team members, but ultimately chose Lewis, explaining, “I can’t miss out on the opportunity to work with a one in a trillion vocalist like Sisaundra.” (Even guest mentor Chris Martin agreed. During rehearsals, the newly single Coldplay frontman called Lewis “a little too good. There’s only a few people in the world who can sing like that.”)
Yet Lewis wasn’t the only singer to impress the coaches Tuesday. Team Usher’s Stevie Jo, a Texas R&B singer with heavy metal roots, and Morgan Wallen, a landscaper with no formal vocal training, transcended One Direction in their performance of “Story of My Life.”
“That was a song originally sung by boys. It was sung by a couple of men on that stage,” Levine announced. “That was awesome.”
The coaches were particularly impressed with Wallen’s previously undiscovered falsetto, a skill so new it surprised the contestant himself. Yet coach Usher, who appeared to be channeling Davy Crockett in a coonskin cap, ultimately chose Stevie Jo, citing his “soulful essence.”
But that was not the end of The Voice journey for Wallen, who was saved by Levine in dramatic fist-bump fashion in the final moments of the show.
“Morgan has rare soulfulness I don’t even think he realizes he has,” Levine explained of his decision. “Seeing that quality in a guy with so little experience is really special.”