Gabe Saporta Marries Erin Fetherston

Gabe Saporta talks about the girl of his dreams in the Cobra Starship hit “You Make Me Feel,” and now he officially has only one woman to sing it to – his new bride, designer Erin Fetherston.

The couple wed Sunday (and the bride wore a gown she designed) at the St. Nicholas Abbey plantation in Barbados, PEOPLE has confirmed.

Saporta, 33, proposed to Fetherston, 31, on New Year’s Eve while on vacation in the Barbados.