Paranormal Activity 2 Star: I'm Too Scared to Watch My Own Films

As a horror film star and self-proclaimed Halloween haunted-house lover, it may seem like it could take a lot to spook Paranormal Activity 2’s Katie Featherston. But the actress, 28, admits it’s her own work that gives her a case of the heebie-jeebies.

“The first time I saw Paranormal 2 was with an audience, and I was terrified,” Featherston tells PEOPLE. “I can not watch either of the Paranormal films alone.”