It wasn’t pretty!
From fighting words to (alleged) actual fighting, it was a week of showdowns here on PEOPLE.com, as four of the five stories that got the strongest reaction from readers involved some kind of trouble.
Luckily, in the middle of it all, Piper Perabo was there to give us something we could love unequivocally.
Below, check out the top five stories on PEOPLE.com this week, as judged by the number of clicks on the emoticons. And let us know what you think of every story by clicking on the icons at the bottom.