As soon as British actor Sam Claflin walked in to audition for the role, Catching Fire director Francis Lawrence knew he’d found his Finnick. But Claflin, 27, didn’t have that same confidence. “I went in there thinking, ‘I’m not going to get this part; I’m not good-looking enough,’” says Claflin. Ironically, that attitude may have worked in his favor. “My perception of Finnick Odair is that he’s actually a very insecure person, and me walking in there being vulnerable, that’s what I had going for me,” he says.