Shay Mitchell on Being Named One of PEOPLE's Most Beautiful: My Grandma Added the Issue to Her Scrapbook!

When we’re not fangirling over Shay Mitchell on Pretty Little Liars, we’re probably talking about her spot-on style or her perfect hair or her amazing complexion. So it’s no surprise that the 28-year-old star nabbed a spot on PEOPLE’s 2015 Most Beautiful list, an honor that her family is still celebrating.

Shay Mitchell styleDonato Sardella/Wireimage

Shailene Woodley Uses What?! To Perfect Her Pout (Plus, 4 More Stars Who Love Food in Their Beauty Routine)

TV Stars Tap Their Creative Sides: Shay Mitchell and Shenae Grimes Now Have Clothing Lines!

Shay Mitchell Is Piperlime's New Holiday 'It Girl'

Shay Mitchell: On the Surprising Trick She Uses to Remove Her Makeup and More!

Pretty Little Liars star Shay Mitchell shares her biggest beauty secrets with PEOPLE.

What We're Buying: $10 Perfume (Loved by One of Our Favorite Stars), the 'It' Bag for Fall, Metallic Sandals & More!

Shay Mitchell's Lifestyle Blog Relaunched! Get a First Look at Her Nail How-To

Our Favorite Fashionista Shay Mitchell Answers the Tough Questions for PEOPLE StyleWatch

Shay Mitchell and Ashley Benson Update Their Hair Color