“We were so picky with what songs we put on this record,” Colton, 26, tells PEOPLE. “And we said a little prayer before every session with the musicians, just praying that it goes well. You get one shot at this.”
Texas teen Danielle Bradbery predicted she wouldn’t sleep at all Monday night. But the Swon Brothers said they’d rest peacefully, knowing they did their best on the final night of competition on season 4 of The Voice.