updated 11/01/2012 AT 9:10 PM ET
•originally published 11/01/2012 AT 8:45 PM ET
Taylor Swift’s love life is more than great inspiration for her hit songs – it’s now a punchline.
“Brad and I were backstage talking about what a strange year this has been,” Underwood said at the start of their funny (and musically-accentuated) routine.
“Just look at sports, I can’t keep track of all these trades,” continued Paisley, as his co-host noted that Tim Tebow is now playing for the New York Jets.